Suda On Line menu Search

Home
Search results for pi,27 in Adler number:
Greek display:    

Headword: Pathos
Adler number: pi,27
Translated headword: affection, passion, emotion
Vetting Status: high
Translation:
The word "affection" is spoken of in two ways, for it is what leads either to destruction or to completion. Thus it is said that a piece of wood is affected by fire, meaning that it is brought to destruction; it is also said that sensations are affected by sensible things,[1] meaning that they are fulfilled and are transformed from a potentiality to an actuality.
And something passes from the affections of the body to the soul, for the soul sympathizes with a body in pain[2] and rejoices with one that is cheerful. Nobody is unaware that the body, when disposed one way or another, interferes with the soul. This would not occur if a certain sympathy[3] did not pass from the condition of the body to the soul, just as the faculty of memory is affected when the rear chamber of the brain is affected.
On affections: the parts of the soul are the five sense-organs, the part that relates to speech, and the thinking part, which is thought.[4] Distortion comes to thought from falsehoods and, due to such a distortion, many affections arise which are causes of instability. The affection itself is a movement of the soul which is irrational and contrary to nature, or an impulse which is excessive.[5] The most generic division of affections is into four: pain, fear, appetite, pleasure. It seems to be[6] that the affections are judgments, for greed is a supposition that money is something fine or noble.[7] And the same thing occurs in the case of drunkenness, intemperance and the others. And pain[8] is an irrational contraction and its types are piety, envy, rivalry, resentment, distress, anxiety, folly, agony, confusion. Pity is the type of pain felt for someone suffering undeservedly; envy is pain over someone else's good fortunes; rivalry is a pain that comes from the fact that another person has what one also has oneself; distress is an oppressive pain; anxiety is a disabling pain that makes it difficult to act; folly is a persistent and growing pain that arises in deliberations; agony is an intense pain; confusion is an irrational and tormenting pain which prevents one from perceiving one's circumstances.
Immortality is an affection of life or some kind of accident: That immortality is an affection of life or some kind of accident will be proven on the ground of the hypothesis that the immortal comes to be from the mortal. For the mortal will not be immortal because of participation in another life but because of some kind of accident and affection. For the same life, in being affected, is immortality. But if life becomes immortality as cause of affection, life would be an affection of immortality. Therefore, if what has been affected is not a type of a particular affection (for the affection of what has been affected is a certain coincidence, i.e. an accident, but not a form), life would not be a type of immortality. For neither is the body a type of sweetness nor the soul a type of pleasure or pain.
This topic has also been treated in the [entry] "immortal", but more broadly there.[9]
Greek Original:
Pathos: hoti to tou pathous onoma dichôs legetai: ê gar to eis phthoran agon ê eis teleiôsin. legetai gar paschein to xulon hupo tou puros, hôs eis phthoran agomenon, legetai paschein kai tas aisthêseis hupo tôn aisthêtôn, anti tou teleiousthai, kai ek dunameôs eis energeian agesthai. hoti ek tôn pathôn tou sômatos diabainei ti pros tên psuchên: algounti gar sunalgei kai euthumounti sunêdetai. hoti kai empodizei autêi to sôma toiôs ê toiôs diakeimenon, oudeis agnoei, hoper ouk an egeneto, ei mê diebainen apo tês pros auto scheseôs sumpatheia tis epi tên psuchên houtôs, hôs tês koilias tou enkephalou tês opisthen pathousês to mnêmoneutikon paschein. peri pathôn: hoti tês psuchês merê ta e# aisthêtêria kai to phônêtikon morion kai to dianoêtikon, hoper estin hê dianoia. ek de tôn pseudôn epigignesthai tên diastrophên epi tên dianoian, aph' hês polla pathê blastanein kai akatastasias aitia. esti de auto to pathos hê alogos kai para phusin psuchês kinêsis ê hormê pleonazousa. tôn pathôn tôn anôtatô genê tessara, lupê, phobos, epithumia, hêdonê. dokei de ta pathê kriseis einai: hê te gar philarguria hupolêpsis esti tou to argurion kalon einai. kai hê methê de kai hê akolasia homoiôs kai ta alla. kai tên men einai sustolên alogon, eidê de autês eleos, phthonos, zêlos, zêlotupia, achthos, enochlêsis, anoia, odunê, sunchusis. eleon men hôs epi anaxiôs kakopathounti, phthonon de lupên ep' allotriois agathois, zêlon de lupên epi tôi allôi pareinai hôn kai autos echei, achthos lupên barunousan, enochlêsin lupên stenochôrousan kai duschôrian paraskeuazousan, anoian lupên ek dialogismôn menousan ê epiteinomenên, odunên lupên epiponon, sunchusin lupên alogon, apokleiousan kai kôluousan ta paronta sunoran. hoti hê athanasia tês zôês pathos estin ê sumptôma ti. hoti de pathos ê sumptôma ti hê athanasia tês zôês, deichthêsetai epi hupothesei têi ek thnêtou athanaton gignesthai: ou gar metalêpsei allês zôês athanaton estai to thnêton, all' hôs sumptômati tini kai pathei: hê gar autê zôê pathousa athanasia estin. ei de pathous aitia hê zôê athanasia ginetai, eiê an pathos hê zôê tês athanasias. ei oun tou pathous tou idiou to peponthos ouk esti genos [sumptôma ti gar kai sumbebêkos to pathos tou peponthotos, all' ouk eidos], oud' an tês athanasias genos eiê hê zôê: oude gar glu- kutêtos to sôma genos oude hêdonês ê lupês psuchê. lelektai peri toutou kai en tôi athanatos, all' entautha platuteron.
Notes:
This main paragraph of this composite entry follows, first, John Philoponus, On Aristotle's de anima 301.9-13 and 155.23-29; then Diogenes Laertius 7.110-112; then Alexander of Aphrodisias, On Aristotle's Topica 353.12-21.
cf. alpha 705, delta 556.
[1] This sentence looks like a brief paraphrase of the opening lines of Aristotle, Physics 7.3: "That everything which undergoes alteration is altered by sensible causes, and that there is alteration only in things that are said to be affected in their own right by sensible things, can be seen from the following considerations" (transl. R.P. Hardie and R.K. Gaye, in J. Barnes, ed. The Complete Works of Aristotle. The Revised Oxford Translation, Princeton 1984).
[2] That is to say, it shares its affection or "feeling" with another thing.
[3] The Greek word is sympatheia, "co-affection", "affinity".
[4] This distinction is Stoic in character (see Diogenes Laertius 7.110). "The faculty of procreation" (to spermatikon) is not mentioned here, although it is listed in the Stoic doxographies on the parts of the soul. In the Stoic sources the "thinking part" (to dianoetikon) is called "the commanding or ruling part" (to hegemonikon). See Diogenes Laertius 7.110 and Nemesius, On the nature of man 72.7-9 (ed. Morani).
[5] This is the canonical Stoic definition of pathos ("affection", "passion", "emotion") attributed to Zeno of Citium, the founder of the Stoic school (see Stobaeus, Excerpts 2.39.5-9, 2.88.8-10 ed. Wachsmuth; Diogenes Laertius 7.110).
[6] To the Stoics (Diogenes Laertius 7.111; Galen, On the Doctrines of Hippocrates and Plato V 1, 292, 17-20 ed. De Lacy).
[7] Every affection or emotional state involves a belief or opinion (doxa) that something is good or bad. The cause of appetite is to believe that a good thing is approaching; that of fear is to believe that a bad thing is approaching (Stobaeus, Excerpts 2.90.8-12 ed. Wachsmuth; Diogenes Laertius 7.111).
[8] The word "pain"(lupe) is not in the text; I follow Diogenes Laertius 7.113, where this definition of pain is given.
[9] alpha 705.
References:
T. Brennan, "The Old Stoic Theory of Emotions", in J. Sihvola, T. Engberg-Pedersen (eds.) The Emotions in Hellenistic Philosophy (Dordrecht/Boston/London, 1998), 21-70
J.M. Cooper, Reason and Emotion. Essays on Ancient Moral Psychology and Ethical Theory (Princeton 1999)
C. Gill, "Did Galen Understand Platonic and Stoic Thinking on Emotions?", in Sihvola, Pedersen (quoted above)
Keywords: definition; ethics; philosophy
Translated by: Marcelo Boeri on 4 November 1999@14:31:52.
Vetted by:
William Hutton on 10 November 1999@00:35:18.
William Hutton on 10 November 1999@20:51:45.
William Hutton on 10 November 1999@23:48:57.
Scott Carson on 2 January 2000@23:58:18.
Scott Carson on 11 February 2000@16:03:22.
Catharine Roth (cosmetic) on 26 February 2002@00:45:57.
David Whitehead (added x-refs; cosmetics) on 11 July 2003@08:37:40.
David Whitehead (another keyword) on 20 November 2005@09:33:23.
David Whitehead (expanded primary note; cosmetics) on 9 August 2013@03:47:38.
David Whitehead (codings) on 21 May 2016@06:21:38.
Catharine Roth on 6 April 2021@23:10:10.
Catharine Roth on 7 April 2021@00:29:39.
Ronald Allen (typos in translation) on 19 May 2021@15:03:15.
Catharine Roth (tweaked translation) on 20 May 2021@00:15:05.

Find      

Test Database Real Database

(Try these tips for more productive searches.)

No. of records found: 1    Page 1

End of search